To clinic directors considering succeeding their sole proprietorship clinic through a business transfer (M&A) without incorporating. This article explains in detail, in line with search intent, the procedures for transferring the trade name, patients, and insurance medical practice designation in a clinic M&A via business transfer, as well as points to note when proceeding with these procedures. M&A Medical (CentralMedience Inc.), as an M&A support institution certified by the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency, supports the smooth business succession of sole proprietorship clinics.
It is possible to proceed with the M&A of a sole proprietorship clinic through a business transfer without incorporating. While it is possible to transfer patients, trade names, and insurance medical practice designations, each procedure requires specialized knowledge and time. Utilizing a reliable M&A support institution is recommended for a smooth succession.
Business Transfer is Fundamental for M&A of Individual Clinics Without Incorporation
In the M&A of clinics operated as sole proprietorships, “business transfer” is the common form of transfer. Business transfer refers to the comprehensive acquisition of the business assets (equipment, supplies, medical records, patient lists, employees, and rights such as “trade name” and “designation as a medical institution”) held by the clinic. This allows for the succession of the business while remaining a sole proprietor without incorporating, or to a new corporation established by the sole proprietor.
Advantages of Business Transfer
- Reduced hassle and cost of incorporation: Since corporate establishment registration and related procedures are unnecessary, M&A can proceed quickly and at a lower cost.
- Flexible succession: It is a format that easily allows for the continuation of the trade name as a sole proprietor or the existing designation as a medical institution.
- Reduced risk of off-balance sheet liabilities: The acquirer can selectively take over the assets and liabilities to be transferred, thus tending to reduce the risk of inheriting unexpected off-balance sheet liabilities.
On the other hand, business transfers can involve complex procedures for transferring individual assets and rights, making expert advice indispensable.
Procedures for Transferring Trade Name, Patients, and Medical Institution Designation
In the M&A of individual clinics, the transfer of elements directly related to business continuity, such as the long-cultivated “trade name,” “patients,” and “insurance medical practice designation,” is particularly important. These are essential for the smooth operation of the clinic after the M&A.
1. Transfer of Trade Name
The trade name of a clinic is a valuable asset directly linked to patient trust and recognition. By clearly stating it as a transferred asset in the business transfer agreement, the new owner (acquirer) can generally take it over. However, if the trade name is strongly associated with a specific individual’s name or is trademarked, separate permission or procedures may be required. It is important to clearly include clauses regarding the permission to use the trade name in the contract.
2. Transfer of Patients
The transfer of patients is one of the most crucial elements for business continuity after M&A. Business transfer agreements typically include clauses regarding the transfer of patient lists (names, contact information, medical history, treatment records, etc.). The acquirer can prevent patient attrition by taking over this information and continuing to provide medical services.
Points to Note Regarding Patient Information Transfer:
- Act on the Protection of Personal Information: The handling of patient personal information must comply with the Act on the Protection of Personal Information. Detailed arrangements must be made in advance between the transferor and acquirer regarding the scope of responsibility for personal information protection and methods for obtaining consent.
- Explanation to Patients: It is important to carefully explain the continuity of medical care to patients and obtain their understanding. Sudden announcements can cause anxiety, so explanations should be given at an appropriate time while monitoring the progress of the M&A.
3. Transfer of Insurance Medical Practice Designation (Designation as an Insurance Medical Institution)
To provide insurance medical services, it is necessary to obtain “designation as an insurance medical institution” from the insurer in each prefecture (such as the Federation of National Health Insurance Organizations or the National Health Insurance Federation). When a sole proprietorship clinic is transferred through a business transfer, the acquirer generally needs to apply for new designation as an insurance medical institution. This is because the designation is tied to the individual transferor and is not automatically transferred.
Overview of Procedures:
- Conclusion of Business Transfer Agreement: A business transfer agreement is concluded between the transferor and acquirer.
- Obtaining a License to Establish a Medical Institution: The acquirer obtains a new license to establish a medical institution at the transferred property (or a new property).
- Application for Designation as an Insurance Medical Institution: After obtaining the license to establish a medical institution, the acquirer applies to the relevant insurer for designation as an insurance medical institution.
- Obtaining Designation: Following examination, the designation is issued.
These procedures take a certain amount of time, so it is essential to proceed with ample time in the M&A schedule. In particular, the examination for designation can take time, and there is a non-zero risk that designation may not be obtained. Therefore, it is indispensable to collaborate with an M&A support institution to consult with insurers in advance and make detailed plans for how to proceed with the procedures.
[Important] Transfer of Designation as an Insurance Medical Institution is Primarily a “New Application.” The designation held by the transferor is not automatically transferred; the acquirer must apply anew. As these procedures take time, it is extremely important to collaborate with experts from the planning stage of the M&A and secure sufficient time.
Market Price and Evaluation Points for Individual Clinic M&A
The valuation (market price) for the M&A of sole proprietorship clinics cannot be definitively stated as “a certain amount.” Generally, the following factors influence the valuation.
Key Factors Affecting Valuation:
- Profitability: Annual sales, profit amount, profit margin. Stable, ongoing profits are particularly valued.
- Location and Region: Potential for patient acquisition, status of competing clinics, surrounding demographics, etc.
- Equipment and Property: Presence of the latest medical equipment, lease terms of the property, size, need for renovation, etc.
- Number and Type of Patients: Stable patient base, repeat visit rate, prevalence of patients with specific conditions or age groups, etc.
- Quality and Number of Employees: The presence of skilled staff is a source of reassurance for business continuity.
- Service Area: Potential for future population growth, needs of regional healthcare, etc.
Estimate of Valuation for Individual Clinic M&A
| Evaluation Item | Estimate | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Business Assets (Equipment, Supplies, etc.) | Market Value Assessment | Consideration of used market prices and depreciation costs |
| Intangible Assets (Goodwill, Patient Lists, etc.) | Several times the operating profit for a few years | Comprehensive judgment of profitability, future prospects, brand strength, etc. Varies significantly by case. |
| Based on Medical Revenue (Sales) | Several months to 1 year | This is only a rough guideline. Profit and asset status are considered more important. |
Note: The above are general estimates, and the valuation can vary significantly depending on the specific circumstances of each clinic. To determine an accurate valuation, professional due diligence (DD) and business valuation are necessary.
Steps to Successfully Complete M&A for an Individual Clinic
A planned and phased approach is important for smoothly proceeding with and successfully completing the M&A of a sole proprietorship clinic. The general steps are outlined below.
-
STEP 1: M&A Consideration and Preparation
Clarify the purpose of the M&A (retirement, lack of successor, business expansion, etc.) and solidify the intention to transfer. Understand your clinic’s strengths and weaknesses, and organize the desired transfer conditions (desired sale price, transfer timing, etc.). -
STEP 2: Selection of M&A Support Institution
Select a reliable M&A support institution (specialized brokerage firm or advisor). Finding a partner with specialized knowledge and a track record who understands your clinic’s situation is key to M&A success. -
STEP 3: Business Valuation and Document Preparation
Together with the selected support institution, conduct a business valuation of your clinic (preparation for due diligence). Prepare necessary documents for the transfer (financial statements, treatment records, equipment list, patient information overview, etc.). -
STEP 4: Search and Selection of Potential Buyers
The support institution will search for and introduce suitable potential buyers (acquirers) after executing a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA). Through meetings, etc., negotiate terms and confirm intentions with candidates. -
STEP 5: Conclusion of Basic Agreement (MOU)
If an agreement is reached on terms, a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) will be concluded, outlining the basic terms of the M&A (transaction format, price range, schedule, etc.). -
STEP 6: Detailed Due Diligence (DD)
The acquirer will conduct a detailed investigation (due diligence) into the financial, legal, and medical practice aspects of the clinic to be transferred. At this stage, the prerequisites for the M&A will be confirmed, and the final price and terms will be adjusted. -
STEP 7: Conclusion of Final Agreement (Share Transfer Agreement or Business Transfer Agreement)
Based on the results of the due diligence, the final M&A agreement (in this case, a business transfer agreement) will be concluded. -
STEP 8: M&A Execution and Closing
Based on the agreement, M&A will be executed through payment of the consideration, transfer of assets, and various licensing procedures (establishment of a medical institution, application for designation as an insurance medical institution, etc.). -
STEP 9: Post-M&A Integration (PMI)
The acquirer will take over the operation of the clinic and proceed with building relationships with patients and employees, integrating the medical treatment system, etc.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Is M&A possible for a sole proprietorship clinic that has not been incorporated?
A1: Yes, it is possible. M&A can be conducted in the form of a business transfer even for sole proprietorship clinics. It is common for businesses to be succeeded by the sole proprietor themselves or by a new corporation established by the sole proprietor, without incorporating.
Q2: What can be transferred in a business transfer?
A2: In a business transfer, business assets held by the clinic (equipment, supplies, medical records, patient lists, employees, designation as a medical institution, trade name, etc.) can be acquired individually or comprehensively. The scope of transfer varies depending on the contract terms.
Q3: How should patients be informed during M&A?
A3: It is important to inform patients carefully and honestly, while monitoring the progress of the M&A. It is also effective to use explanatory materials or briefing sessions to ensure understanding, taking care not to cause anxiety regarding the continuity of medical care or the new doctors and staff. M&A support institutions can provide advice on the timing and content of explanations.
Q4: Is the designation as an insurance medical institution automatically transferred?
A4: No, the designation as an insurance medical institution is generally not automatically transferred. The acquirer must apply for new designation as an insurance medical institution to the relevant insurer after obtaining the license to establish a medical institution. As these procedures take time, it is important to collaborate with experts from the planning stage of the M&A.
M&A for individual clinics involves many specialized knowledge and procedures, making a reliable partner indispensable for smooth business succession. M&A Medical (CentralMedience Inc.), as an M&A support institution certified by the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency, will fully support your clinic’s business succession with its extensive experience and specialized knowledge.
📊 FREE ASSESSMENT
Free Simple Appraisal in 1 Minute / 3 Questions
We will provide an estimated transfer price for your medical institution on the spot.
Strictly confidential, no sales calls, receive report via a single email.