📖 Approx. 7 min read
The Importance of Due Diligence in Clinic Succession
M&A and business succession for clinics are not merely asset transfers; they are critical processes that influence the continuity of the medical institution, patient impact, and future business development. For medical corporations in particular, due to their unique corporate structure and the legal/institutional constraints on their operations, thorough and comprehensive due diligence (DD) is indispensable. DD serves as a compass to identify risks and hidden liabilities of the target clinic beforehand, calculate a fair valuation, and ensure smooth post-succession operations. This article focuses on the succession of clinics structured as medical corporations, explaining the specific check items that experts scrutinize.
Utilizing the Medical Corporation DPF (Due Diligence Package Format)
In M&A and business succession involving medical corporations, in addition to general corporate acquisition DD items, there are specific confirmation points tailored to the characteristics of medical corporations. To efficiently and comprehensively review these, the use of a standardized checklist or format, known as the DPF (Due Diligence Package Format), has been advancing within the medical industry. The DPF is designed to comprehensively check issues unique to medical corporations, such as approval procedures in the general meeting of members, valuation of membership interests, the existence of funds and their repayment methods, the status of medical fees receivables, compliance with facility standards, and the transfer procedures for licenses and permits. This allows the acquiring party to efficiently identify risks in a short period, and the selling party to smoothly provide the necessary information.
| Check Item | Details | Points to Note |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Status & Organization | Type of medical corporation (association/foundation), establishment history, articles of incorporation/donation charter | Review minutes of general meetings of members and board meetings, member registry |
| Members & Officers | Composition of members, decision-making process in the general meeting of members | History of member changes, regulations regarding appointment and dismissal of officers |
| Assets & Liabilities | Fixed assets (land, buildings, medical equipment), current assets (medical fees receivables), liabilities (loans, accrued expenses) | Assess collectability of medical fees receivables, scrutinize accrued expenses (personnel costs, outsourcing fees, etc.) |
| Financial Status | Financial statements and tax returns for the past several years | Impact of medical fee revisions, consistency with regional medical plans |
| Licenses & Notifications | Establishment permit, various notifications (medical insurance provider, workers’ compensation designation, etc.) | Expiration dates of permits, name change procedures associated with succession |
| Medical Fees | Balance of medical fees receivables, status of claim review and payment | Past rejection and assessment rates, instances of fraudulent billing |
| Medical Equipment | Depreciation, maintenance contracts, lease agreements | Operational status of major equipment, transfer of maintenance contracts |
| Contracts | Lease agreements, maintenance contracts, service contracts (cleaning, catering, etc.) | Review contract terms, termination clauses, transferability |
| Human Resources & Labor | Number of employees, employment contracts, work rules, retirement benefit system | Status of social insurance and labor insurance enrollment, unpaid overtime |
| Litigation & Disputes | Ongoing lawsuits, administrative sanctions, complaint history | Past medical accidents, handling of patient complaints |
Specific Issues for Medical Corporations: Membership Interests, Member Changes, and Fund Repayments
The most complex and critical issues in business succession for medical corporations are “membership interests,” “member changes,” and “fund repayments.” Firstly, for medical corporations with membership interests (associational medical corporations with capital contributions), the valuation and transfer procedures of these interests are crucial. The valuation of membership interests must be carefully conducted, considering not only net assets but also future profitability and the regional healthcare system. Approval at the general meeting of members and tax implications (e.g., capital gains tax) must also be confirmed. Secondly, member changes are procedures that affect the core of a medical corporation and require adherence to the articles of incorporation and resolutions from the general meeting of members. In particular, the composition and selection process of members significantly impact the corporation’s decision-making capacity and continuity, necessitating meticulous review. Lastly, fund repayment arises when a medical corporation has established funds at its inception. The balance of these funds, repayment methods, and timing must be clarified and incorporated into the post-succession financial plan. These issues require specialized knowledge and experience, making close collaboration with experts such as M&A advisors, tax accountants, and lawyers highly recommended.
Medical Fee Receivables and Challenges in Regional Medical Plans
Medical fee receivables, which constitute the majority of a clinic’s revenue, are among the most important items in due diligence. By reviewing past medical fee statements (receipts) and understanding the status of billing, rejections, and assessments, the collectability of receivables can be evaluated. Furthermore, the absence of fraudulent or improper billing is also a potential future risk, requiring detailed verification. Additionally, “regional medical plans” have become increasingly important. Regional medical plans are national strategies to balance future medical demand and supply, outlining the roles of each medical institution. Before succession, it is essential to thoroughly consider the role the clinic to be succeeded should play within the regional medical plan, and whether the necessary management resources (personnel, equipment, funds) can be secured to fulfill that role. Business development that deviates from the regional medical plan could lead to risks in medical fee calculation or future administrative guidance.
Flow for Confirming Regional Medical Plans in Succession Consideration
- Understand the Regional Medical Plan: Review materials on regional medical plans published by the relevant local government and Koseikyoku (regional bureaus of the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare) to grasp the local medical demand and the direction of future hospital function differentiation and consolidation.
- Analyze the Target Clinic’s Current Status: Position the target clinic’s medical services, patient demographics, and facilities within the current regional healthcare provision system.
- Consider Future Roles: Based on the purpose of the regional medical plan, consider the roles the clinic should undertake after succession (e.g., acute care, rehabilitation, home care, preventive medicine).
- Incorporate into Business Plan: Translate the considered future roles into a concrete business plan (treatment plan, capital investment plan, staffing plan, financial plan).
- Coordinate with Authorities: If necessary, exchange information with the relevant local government and Koseikyoku to confirm and consult on consistency with the regional medical plan.
Transfer of Licenses and Permits, and Facility Standard Compliance
The transfer of various licenses and permits is essential for the continuity of medical services in clinic succession. Establishment permits for medical corporations, designations as medical insurance providers, workers’ compensation designated institutions, and medical institutions under the Livelihood Protection Act, are generally valid after succession, but require name changes and notifications. Failure to complete these procedures can lead to an inability to claim medical fees or result in legal issues. It is particularly important to consult with the relevant administrative bodies (e.g., public health centers,厚生局) in advance to confirm the necessary documents and procedures for smooth post-succession operations. Furthermore, compliance with “facility standards,” which are crucial for medical fee calculation, is another item to be verified during due diligence. It is necessary to confirm whether the facility standards set for each medical specialty or service are met and can continue to be met after succession. Failure to meet these standards carries the risk of reduced medical fees or retroactive claims for repayment.
Tax Considerations and Consultation with Experts
Tax implications are extremely important in M&A and business succession for clinics. Particularly for medical corporations, various schemes such as the transfer of membership interests, dissolution/liquidation of the medical corporation, or business transfer can be considered, each with different tax treatments. For example, if membership interests are transferred, the transferor is subject to income tax and resident tax as capital gains. There are also cases where business tax is imposed on the medical corporation itself (non-medical corporation taxation). To minimize these tax risks and optimize the tax burden, consulting with tax professionals such as tax accountants from an early stage is essential. Professionals with expertise specifically in medical corporations can provide accurate advice on complex issues such as the valuation of membership interests, handling of funds, carryforward of net operating losses, and consumption tax treatment. Engaging experts from the initial stages of M&A or business succession can help avoid unexpected tax risks and facilitate a smooth succession.
【Examples of Tax Risks in Succession Consideration】
- Overstated tax filings due to incorrect valuation of membership interests
- Incorrect tax treatment regarding the repayment of funds
- Deficiencies in requirements for carrying forward net operating losses
- Errors in input tax credits for consumption tax
- Lack of awareness regarding non-medical corporation taxation for business tax
※The above are examples and may vary depending on individual circumstances.
Conclusion: Careful Due Diligence in Collaboration with Experts
M&A and business succession for clinics are crucial steps to ensure the perpetuity of the medical institution and stable provision of medical care to patients. For medical corporations in particular, due to the numerous issues related to their unique corporate structure and operations, careful and comprehensive due diligence by experts is indispensable. A wide range of checks are necessary, from fundamental matters of corporate operation such as the valuation of membership interests, member changes, and fund repayments, to medical fee receivables, regional medical plans, licenses and facility standards, and tax considerations. At M&A Medical, our team of experts, well-versed in M&A and business succession for medical institutions, conducts meticulous due diligence from both the buyer’s and seller’s perspectives, supporting smooth and successful successions. Please feel free to contact us for consultation.
Consult M&A Medical for Medical Succession
M&A Medical is a specialized M&A and business succession support service for medical institutions. As an M&A support institution certified by the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency, we support the success of transfers for clinics and medical corporations struggling with a lack of successors, as well as strategic acquisitions, on a success fee basis.
- Initial consultation and preliminary assessment are free
- No retainer or monthly fees (success fee only)
- Strict confidentiality (proceeds under NDA)
- Services available nationwide in all 47 prefectures and for all medical specialties
Please consult us early in your consideration phase, whether you just want to know the market value, have no successor, or are considering joining a group.